☰ Main Menu
Generative Artificial Intelligence for Reviewer
Reviewers should exercise particular caution when using generative artificial intelligence or other AI-assisted technologies during peer review. Submitted manuscripts may contain unpublished, confidential, proprietary, or sensitive information. Such information must not be exposed to external AI systems in a manner that could compromise confidentiality or intellectual property.
Restrictions on AI Use
- Do not upload the complete manuscript to publicly available generative AI systems.
- Do not upload substantial portions of the manuscript into external AI tools.
- Do not enter confidential reviewer reports or editorial correspondence into AI systems.
- Do not disclose author identities or other confidential peer-review information to AI tools.
- Do not use AI-generated analysis as a substitute for the reviewer's own scholarly judgment.
- Do not rely on AI-generated references without independently verifying their existence and relevance.
- Do not allow AI tools to make the final recommendation regarding acceptance, revision, or rejection.
Permitted Limited Assistance
Where permitted by applicable journal policy and without exposing confidential manuscript content, AI-assisted tools may be used for limited administrative or language-related purposes. Examples may include improving the grammar of a reviewer's independently written comments or assisting with general organization.
- The reviewer must verify all AI-assisted output.
- The reviewer remains fully responsible for the final review report.
- AI-generated statements must not introduce inaccurate criticism or unsupported claims.
- AI assistance must not compromise confidentiality or intellectual property.
Reviewer Accountability
The reviewer remains personally responsible for the confidentiality, accuracy, originality, fairness, and ethical integrity of the review regardless of whether AI-assisted technologies are used. AI tools must never replace the reviewer's expertise, critical evaluation, or independent judgment.


